Best Reusable Makeup Remover Wipes: Comparing Microfibre, Cotton and Bamboo

Guide to the Best Materials for Reusable Makeup Remover Wipes: Which One to Choose?

When it comes to make-up removal wipes, it is important to strike a balance between effectiveness, gentleness for the skin and sustainability. In recent years, the market has come up with many options, but not all of them work in the same way. In this article, I will share our experience in testing various reusable make-up removal wipe materials and find out which ones have proven to be the best (and worst) at removing make-up, bearing in mind that of all those tested over the years, we have only included a few of the most commonly used ones.

The importance of material selection

Before delving into the ranking of materials, it is useful to understand why the choice of the right fabric or yarn is crucial. Not only does it affect the effectiveness of make-up removal, it also determines skin compatibility and possible environmental impact. We have conducted numerous tests to develop our ideal make-up removal wipe, examining the pros and cons of different materials, and even when we thought we had found the most suitable material in terms of fabric properties and environmental impact, the tests were not comforting and we had to start all over again.

6. TNT (Nonwoven) Disposable Makeup Remover Wipes

Non-woven (TNT) disposable wipes are very common and often pre-moistened with cleaning solutions. However, for our project, they were not sufficiently effective.

Pro : Comfortable and quick to use, cheap.

Cons: High environmental impact, non-biodegradable, often contain cleansing solutions that can be irritating (except for those with the ‘clinically tested’ label). They do not guarantee complete cleansing of the face.

Verdict: Last on the list. Although they are easy to use, their high ecological footprint and lack of gentleness on the skin, especially sensitive skin which then becomes reddened upon use, make them an unsuitable choice.

5. Biodegradable Cotton Disposable Wipes

Biodegradable cotton wipes, generally in pad format, seem a more ecological choice, but in practice have not proved much better than non-woven wipes at removing make-up.

Pro: Biodegradable, less environmentally impactful.

Cons: Disposable, therefore still producing waste. Non-performing in removing make-up. 

Verdict: Penultimate in the ranking. Although biodegradable, they remain inefficient and unsustainable in the long run.

4. Natural Reusable Cotton

Natural cotton is a delicate and reusable material, but when it comes to waterproof make-up, it is not always up to the task. Although it has always been used for towels and bathrobes, it has other excellent qualities but is not suitable for this type of project.

Pro: Natural fibre, reusable. Reduces environmental impact compared to disposable versions.

Cons: It does not effectively remove water-resistant make-up and wears faster than other materials.

Verdict: A good ecological option, but not effective enough to be the best choice.

3. Bamboo Wipes

Bamboo is a fast-growing, pesticide-free material, making it an environmentally friendly choice, a step ahead of cotton. However, bamboo wipes do not surpass microfibre wipes in effectiveness.

Pro: skin-friendly, biodegradable.

Cons: Less durable than other materials and not very effective on waterproof make-up.

Verdict: A solid choice for those seeking a natural alternative, but with some limitations in terms of durability and effectiveness.

2. Traditional Microfibre Wipes

Traditional microfibre was a great discovery, it is very effective in removing make-up without the need for harsh chemicals.

Pro: Effective, washable and reusable, gentle on the skin.

Cons: Being a synthetic material, it requires careful handling during washing, following the manufacturer's instructions.

Verdict: An excellent option, especially for those who want an effective and reusable product. The only downside is the release of microparticles.

1. Microfibre Wipes with Silver Ions

Finally, our number one choice: microfibre wipes enriched with silver ions. This combination offers maximum effectiveness on make-up and hygiene.

Pro: Extremely effective even on waterproof make-up, antibacterial thanks to silver ions, reusable and very durable.

Cons: Like traditional microfibre, it requires careful handling during washing, following the manufacturer's instructions, but the benefits in both durability and efficiency far outweigh this.

Verdict: The best option available. Antibacterial action combined with efficacy and durability make these wipes perfect for frequent and safe use on all skin types.

Conclusion: Which is the best choice?

After testing several solutions, microfibre wipes with silver ions proved to be the ideal choice. They offer complete make-up removal, antibacterial protection and excellent durability. If you are looking for a product that combines effectiveness, hygiene and respect for the skin, this is the best solution.

If you have come this far in reading our article, we thank you very much.

Final tips for choosing your make-up removal wipe

• Consider the type of make-up you use: If you use waterproof products, opt for microfibre.

• Consider the environmental impact: Prefer reusable and biodegradable solutions, but pay attention to effectiveness and your skin type.

• Choose according to your skin: If you have sensitive skin, gentle materials such as bamboo or silver ion wipes might be perfect for you.

If you would like to try our silver ion wipes, you can discover them here: [product link].

Comparison table